The Black American Story
Educator Hub / Activity

Documented or conspiracy?

A 40-minute media-literacy activity. Students rate real claims about Black history, then check them against the evidence. It teaches the difference between documented history, open debate and claims that don't hold up.

Grades 9–12 & college~40 minutesC3: D3.1, D3.2, D4.1
Interactive version

Steps

  1. Rate it (10 min). In pairs, students rate each claim below before looking anything up: Documented, Partly substantiated, Debated, Unproven or Misleading.
  2. Check it (20 min). Each pair investigates two claims using the linked story and its sources.
  3. Report (10 min). Pairs share: what evidence settled it, and did their first guess hold up?

Rating scale

See what each rating means.

Worksheet

#ClaimYour ratingEvidence you found
1The FBI ran a secret program to disrupt Black political organizations.____________________
2The FBI tried to discredit Martin Luther King Jr.____________________
3The federal government drew maps rating Black neighborhoods as risky for lending.____________________
4An FBI informant infiltrated the Black Panther Party and gave police Fred Hampton's floor plan.____________________
5The USDA discriminated against Black farmers in lending.____________________
6Researchers in the Tuskegee study infected Black men with syphilis.____________________
7The 13th Amendment's authors wrote the punishment exception specifically to re-enslave Black people.____________________
8Contra-linked traffickers sold cocaine in the U.S. while the CIA kept working with them.____________________
9The CIA deliberately created the crack epidemic to target Black neighborhoods.____________________
10The government was involved in assassinating Martin Luther King Jr.____________________
11Two men were wrongly convicted of killing Malcolm X because evidence was withheld.____________________
12Airplanes were used during the attack on Greenwood in 1921.____________________
13The U.S. government created HIV/AIDS to harm Black people.____________________

Answer key (for teachers)

  1. Documented. COINTELPRO's "Black Nationalist" program began in 1967. Its files were stolen and leaked in 1971 and investigated by the Senate's Church Committee. Source story
  2. Documented. Wiretaps, hotel bugs, and an anonymous 1964 letter are documented in the Church Committee's case study. Source story
  3. Documented. HOLC maps graded neighborhoods; the FHA manual recommended racial covenants. All maps are digitized. Source story
  4. Documented. William O'Neal's role is established in court records and FBI files from Hampton v. Hanrahan. Source story
  5. Documented. The government settled Pigford v. Glickman (1999) and Pigford II (2010) for more than $2 billion. Source story
  6. Misleading. The men already had syphilis. The government withheld treatment for decades and lied to them, which is the documented injustice. (Researchers did deliberately infect people in Guatemala in the 1940s, a separate study.) Source story
  7. Misleading. The exception language was copied from the 1787 Northwest Ordinance. What is documented is that Southern states quickly exploited it through Black Codes and convict leasing. Source story
  8. Partly substantiated. The 1989 Kerry Committee and the 1998 CIA Inspector General report confirm drug trafficking by Contra-linked figures and CIA relationships with alleged traffickers. Source story
  9. Unproven. No investigation has found evidence of a deliberate plan to create crack or to target Black communities. The documented facts are serious without that claim. Source story
  10. Debated. A 1999 Memphis civil jury found a conspiracy. A 2000 Justice Department investigation found no reliable evidence. The question remains contested. Source story
  11. Documented. In 2021 the Manhattan DA found the FBI and NYPD withheld evidence. Muhammad Aziz and Khalil Islam were exonerated. Source story
  12. Strong evidence. Many survivor accounts describe planes firing on residents or dropping incendiaries; the 2001 Oklahoma commission accepted that planes were used. Exactly what they did is still debated. Source story
  13. Unproven. HIV crossed into humans from primates decades before AIDS was identified. The claim was amplified by a documented Soviet disinformation campaign in the 1980s. Distrust rooted in Tuskegee is real; this specific claim is not supported. Source story