Elizabeth Key
A woman of African descent took colonial Virginia to court, argued she was free, and won.
What was happening?
In the 1650s, Virginia's labor system mixed English indentured servants with Africans whose legal status was still being defined. Some Africans were held for life; some gained freedom and even land.
What happened?
Elizabeth Key, daughter of an enslaved African woman and English planter Thomas Key, sued after being held past any term of service. In 1656 she won her freedom.
Why?
Her case exposed a gap that threatened the planters' growing investment in African labor: a child of an English father could claim freedom.
How did Black people respond?
Key used the colony's own legal tools against it: her paternity, her baptism, and the terms of her indenture. Her lawyer, William Grinstead, later became her husband.
What changed?
She and her son walked free. The case proved Africans could use the courts.
What happened next?
In 1662 Virginia passed a law declaring that a child's status would follow the mother, closing the path Key had used and making slavery hereditary.
How could this still matter today?
The pattern shows up again and again in this story: a legal victory by a Black person is followed by a new law designed to stop the next one.
Evidence & sources
Evidence rating: What the ratings mean
- Court record · 1655–1656Key v. Mottrom petition and General Assembly ruling · Virginia colonial records
Records of the suit survive in Northumberland County court books and Virginia General Assembly records.Northumberland County Record Book, 1652–1658; Hening, Statutes at Large.
Related stories
- 1662The 1662 LawOne sentence made slavery inherited.
- 1781Elizabeth FreemanShe heard "all men are born free." Then she sued.
- March 6, 1857Dred Scott"No rights which the white man was bound to respect."
Cite this page
APAThe Black American Story. (2026). Elizabeth Key. https://www.theblackamericanstory.com/stories/elizabeth-key/MLA
"Elizabeth Key." The Black American Story, 2026, https://www.theblackamericanstory.com/stories/elizabeth-key/. Accessed [date].
Chicago"Elizabeth Key." The Black American Story. 2026. https://www.theblackamericanstory.com/stories/elizabeth-key/.