America Declares Liberty While Preserving Slavery
Essential question
How did the new nation declare liberty while protecting slavery?
Objectives
Students will be able to:
- Analyze the three-fifths clause and its effect on political power.
- Explain how Elizabeth Freeman used Massachusetts' constitution to win her freedom.
Standards
- AP African American Studies: Unit 2: Freedom, Enslavement, and Resistance (alignment is approximate; check the current Course and Exam Description).
- C3 Framework (grades 9–12): D2.His.1 (historical context), D2.His.14 (causes and effects), D3.1 (gathering and evaluating sources), D4.1 (constructing evidence-based arguments).
- State standards: add your state's codes here.
Readings (on this site)
- The Three-Fifths Clause (1787): The Constitution counted enslaved people as three-fifths of a person, adding to the political power of the people who enslaved them.
- Elizabeth Freeman (1781): An enslaved woman known as Mum Bett used Massachusetts' new constitution to win her freedom in court.
Primary sources
- The Constitution of the United States (1787), National Archives. Art. I §2 (apportionment), Art. I §9 (1808 trade clause), Art. IV §2 (fugitive clause).
- Brom and Bett v. John Ashley, Esq. (1781), Berkshire County Court of Common Pleas. The jury found for the plaintiffs and awarded damages of thirty shillings.
Lesson sequence
1. Warm-up · 5 min
Read "all men are born free and equal." Who was included when it was written? Who was not?
2. Context · 10 min
Project the interactive era and read the era summary together: "The new nation declared that all men are created equal, then wrote slavery's protections into its Constitution." Ask students to predict what "the system" and "the response" will be.
3. Main activity · 20 min
Split the class. Group A reads the three-fifths clause and calculates how it changed representation. Group B reads Elizabeth Freeman's story. Each group teaches the other in three minutes.
4. Discussion · 10 min
- Who gained power from counting enslaved people as three-fifths of a person?
- How did Freeman turn the founders' words into a legal tool?
- Where else have Black Americans forced the country to live up to its written promises?
5. Exit ticket · 5 min
Explain the three-fifths clause in your own words in two sentences.
Differentiation
- Support: pair students, and use the story's one-sentence summary and "What happened?" section as the core reading.
- Extension: have students evaluate one source using the site's evidence ratings and explain the rating.
- Classroom tip: each story page prints as a clean handout.
Student handout
Name: ____________________ Date: __________
Essential question: How did the new nation declare liberty while protecting slavery?
The system (what people faced):
______________________________________________
The response (what people did):
______________________________________________
Evidence (cite a source):
______________________________________________
Exit ticket: Explain the three-fifths clause in your own words in two sentences.
______________________________________________