The Price of Resistance
Essential question
What did resistance cost, and why does it matter to know each person individually?
Objectives
Students will be able to:
- Describe the circumstances of individual cases accurately.
- Explain how families and communities pursued justice.
Standards
- AP African American Studies: Unit 4: Movements and Debates (alignment is approximate; check the current Course and Exam Description).
- C3 Framework (grades 9–12): D2.His.1 (historical context), D2.His.14 (causes and effects), D3.1 (gathering and evaluating sources), D4.1 (constructing evidence-based arguments).
- State standards: add your state's codes here.
Readings (on this site)
- Emmett Till (Aug 28, 1955): A 14-year-old from Chicago was murdered in Mississippi. His mother's choice changed the movement.
- Medgar Evers (June 12, 1963): Mississippi's NAACP field secretary was assassinated in his own driveway.
- Four Girls (Sept 15, 1963): Klansmen bombed the 16th Street Baptist Church, killing Addie Mae Collins, Denise McNair, Carole Robertson and Cynthia Wesley.
- Chaney, Goodman & Schwerner (June 21, 1964): Three civil rights workers were murdered by Klansmen working with a sheriff's deputy.
- Malcolm X (Feb 21, 1965): Malcolm X was assassinated in Harlem. Decades later, two of the men convicted were exonerated.
Primary sources
- Prosecutive Report of Investigation Concerning Emmett Till (2006), Federal Bureau of Investigation. FBI reinvestigation.
- State of Mississippi v. Byron De La Beckwith (1994), Hinds County Circuit Court. Conviction 31 years later.
- 16th Street Baptist Church Bombing files (1963–2002), FBI. Case files.
- United States v. Price, 383 U.S. 787 (1966), U.S. Supreme Court. Upheld federal charges.
- Motion to vacate convictions of Muhammad Aziz and Khalil Islam (Nov 2021), Manhattan District Attorney. Joint motion after a 22-month investigation.
Lesson sequence
1. Warm-up · 5 min
Why might it matter to describe each death individually instead of as a number?
2. Context · 10 min
Project the interactive era and read the era summary together: "Organizers, children and bystanders were killed. Each case had its own circumstances, and each one should be known by name." Ask students to predict what "the system" and "the response" will be.
3. Main activity · 20 min
Each student researches one person on the Price of Resistance page and presents: who they were, what happened, who was responsible, and what justice (if any) followed and when.
4. Discussion · 10 min
- How did Mamie Till-Mobley's decision change the movement?
- Why did some prosecutions take decades?
- What patterns do you see across cases?
5. Exit ticket · 5 min
Write one sentence honoring the person you researched with a specific fact.
Differentiation
- Support: pair students, and use the story's one-sentence summary and "What happened?" section as the core reading.
- Extension: have students evaluate one source using the site's evidence ratings and explain the rating.
- Classroom tip: each story page prints as a clean handout.
Student handout
Name: ____________________ Date: __________
Essential question: What did resistance cost, and why does it matter to know each person individually?
The system (what people faced):
______________________________________________
The response (what people did):
______________________________________________
Evidence (cite a source):
______________________________________________
Exit ticket: Write one sentence honoring the person you researched with a specific fact.
______________________________________________